The Tale of the Two Voids

There is never nothing in nothingness.

One word, two places

Void. Emptiness. Nothing. The dark. The same few words are used for two places on the path that could hardly be further apart. One is the dark we dissolve into. The other is the absolute beyond the fourth. One is an absence; the other, a fullness.

Because the words are the same, the two are often confused. Those who reached the first void wrote of it as the end. Those who read of the second imagine a blank. Both mistakes are costly.

The first void: the dark that dissolves

Dreamless Sleep · Kalamass · The Abyss

Beyond the dream there is a place where the images thin and fall away. Nothing is perceived on the face of the deep. This is the first void: the darkness of dreamless sleep, entered awake.

What it is

How it feels

Darkness, sometimes close enough to suffocate. The breath slows, or seems to stop. Fear rises as the self loosens: the fear of not being. And afterwards, a remembered gap, and a bliss that is never forgotten.

Its Danger

To mistake it for the end. Some stop in the dark and build a teaching around nothingness. Others stop at the information, and build a system around the voice. The first void is a door, not a destination.

Between the two

The Crossing

At the end of the dreamless, having stayed the watcher, you are the wisdom and the information. Then awareness slips through the key whole into the fourth, and the voices fall silent. What dies in the first void is the self. What waits beyond is not more emptiness, but what the emptiness was hiding.

The second void: the void that moves

ŚŪNYA BEYOND THE FOURTH · KHA · THE ABSOLUTE OF INFINITE LIFE

Beyond the fourth, past nirvāṇa, the maps speak of the void again. But this void is not the dark. It is playful, full, restless: the void that moves. Not a void at all, but the absolute of infinite life.

What it is

How it feels

Vast, alive, intimate and free. Awe and joy as one. Not the silence of nothing, but the silence of everything at once.

The Choice

In nirvāṇa you are still aware, and that awareness makes a choice possible. The void does not call you; the choice is yours, and within you a calling as to which way to go. To dissolve into the infinite afterlife, as you will when the vessel finally falls. Or to return to the world, to live awake and perhaps to help others across. There is no wrong answer.

Reflections on the experience

Quotes of the Fourth

From the traditions, on the fourth: awareness the same through waking, dream and deep sleep, the words in red speak of the fourth. See also Quotes of the Fourth.

For the yogi whose intellect is firm (and unwavering), the reality which is the goal, namely, the supreme light of consciousness, having become firm and attained a state of concentration, comes forth by the dissolving away of the mind and the destruction of the latent traces (of past Karma) within the End of the Twelve which is the Void beyond the Void (śūnyātiśūnya), or else within suṣumnā which is the Middle Abode.

Ānandabhaṭṭa · trans. Mark S. G. Dyczkowski, Vijñānabhairava Tantra

Then in that great sky, when the Sun and Moon dissolve away, the dull-minded (yogi is cast down) into a state like that of deep sleep. The awakened, however, remain lucid.

Ānandabhaṭṭa · trans. Mark S. G. Dyczkowski, Vijñānabhairava Tantra

Waking, where something is known and duality is born; dreaming, the light of the outer world; deep sleep, darkness once more. Knowing these states as the very form of Bhairava, one holds infinite light.

Vijñānabhairava Tantra, v. 86 · rendered from the Sanskrit

He never dreams, for he always remains the same during day and night. He is left with just his body.

Turīyātītāvadhūta Upaniṣad · trans. Patrick Olivelle, Saṃnyāsa Upaniṣads (Oxford, 1992)

He has torn asunder the web of delusion, and he sees everything as if it were a dream. By his very nature he is supremely steadfast, and he goes about as if in deep sleep.

Laghu-Avadhūta Upaniṣad · trans. Patrick Olivelle, Saṃnyāsa Upaniṣads (Oxford, 1992)

Śiva is his yogic sleep.

His watchword is not emptiness, but the existence of the supreme lord.

Śiva, the fourth, who is the support of the universe and space, is his sacrificial string.

Nirvāṇa Upaniṣad · trans. Patrick Olivelle, Saṃnyāsa Upaniṣads (Oxford, 1992)

When one discovers this Joy of Awareness, and stabilizes the realization that Awareness is one with body, etc.—even while they are perceivable—that is called ‘embodied liberation’.

Kṣemarāja, Pratyabhijñā-hṛdaya, sūtra 16 · trans. Christopher D. Wallis, The Recognition Sutras

Not a void, but the absolute of infinite life.

Piṇḍa to Kha
← All essays